Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sheila M. HUMPHREYS's avatar

Eli sounds like a great and timely talk

Expand full comment
Jack Jordan's avatar

I'm looking forward to your presentation! Speaking of the Declaration on Memorial Day, may I share a thought regarding the meaning of "liberty" and "the pursuit of happiness"?

Whatever any scholar said about the "definition" should be viewed with circumspection. I submit that what is and should be controlling (regarding the founding of our nation and the meaning of our Constitution) is what people who fought for them thought the concepts "liberty" and "pursuit of happiness" meant for them and the people for whom they fought.

Have you read "American Scripture: Making the Declaration of Independence" by Pauline Maier? I recommend it highly. The statements in that book that I viewed as most insightful included the following on pp. 131-132, 160.

"The Declaration was" designed "to be disseminated" promptly "by print" and "the printer John Dunlap produced a broadside version the day after it was adopted." It also was "designed" to be "read aloud at public gatherings." Significantly, the "Declaration" was designed "for the ear as well as the eye," and "above all" that was true of the "eloquent preamble." The first two paragraphs of the Declaration are "the most sacred of all American political scriptures." And "when the Declaration was read listeners heard mainly what was already in their heads."

The meanings of "liberty" and "the pursuit of happiness" that matter most are the meanings in the minds of the people who voluntarily sacrificed their own lives, their own limbs, their own liberty and their own happiness for those concepts. Economists say that a thing is worth what people pay for it. So anyone who wants to know what "liberty" and "pursuit of happiness" mean, should consider what they mean to soldiers, not merely to scholars.

Perhaps the best soldiers to look to for answers and examples were General Washington, Nathanael Greene, Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Paine. President Lincoln is another. President Lincoln did not wear a military uniform, but as Commander in Chief, he led and thought very much about liberty as Washington did.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts